What Happened to Daddy and Kays Pizza & Cheesecakes in Fostoria?
- What is Daddy and Kay’s Pizza & Cheesecakes known for in Fostoria, OH 44830? Daddy and Kay’s Pizza & Cheesecakes is Fostoria’s top spot for New York-style pizza and handmade cheesecakes, blending crispy thin crusts with fresh toppings like pepperoni, sausage, and bacon. Unlike chain competitors like Domino’s or Marco’s, our all-meat pizza and pickle pizza twists have earned rave reviews as the best pizza in Fostoria, OH, since opening in 2020.
- Where is Daddy and Kay’s Pizza & Cheesecakes located in Fostoria, OH? We’re at 112 W Tiffin St, Fostoria, OH 44830, in a historic spot that was once a bowling alley—adding a fun, nostalgic vibe not found at places like Fostoria Pizza Palace or Jac & Do’s. Easy access for locals near the Fostoria RailPark, with wheelchair-accessible entry and outdoor seating.
- What are the hours for Daddy and Kay’s in Fostoria, OH 44830? We’re open Tuesday through Sunday from 11:30 AM to 8:00 PM, closed Mondays for fresh prep. This consistent schedule beats the varying hours at Main Street Pizza, ensuring reliable pizza delivery in Fostoria OH or dine-in for families.
- How do I order pizza delivery from Daddy and Kay’s in Fostoria, OH? Order online via our site (daddyandkayspizza.com) or apps like DoorDash and Slice for fast delivery to Fostoria, OH 44830—often under 30 minutes. Get 10% off first orders, outpacing delivery fees at competitors like Little Caesars or Marco’s Pizza.
- What types of pizza does Daddy and Kay’s offer in Fostoria? From classic cheese and pepperoni to specialties like taco pizza, pickle pizza, and deluxe with salami, ham, sausage, and bacon, our NY-style pies use handmade dough. Reviewers call our pizza the best in Fostoria OH, fresher than Jac & Do’s or Fostoria Pizza Palace’s larger but soggier options.
- What cheesecakes are available at Daddy and Kay’s Pizza & Cheesecakes? Indulge in our signature New York-style cheesecakes, including Reese’s peanut butter cup mash-ups, strawberry shortcake, and buckeye flavors—mini cups or whole 9-inch pies. No other Fostoria spot like Red’s Pizza or Poppy’s matches our “cheesecake masters” status, as per 4.8/5 reviews.
- Does Daddy and Kay’s have foldovers or calzones in Fostoria, OH? Yes! Our housemade foldovers come stuffed with options like ham and cheese, steak and peppers, or chicken BLT, baked golden with garlic butter. These beat the basic subs at Main Street Pizza, with customers raving about the unique bread topped with parmesan and basil.
- What appetizers pair best with pizza at Daddy and Kay’s in Fostoria? Try our pizza fries (crispy fries topped with pepperoni, mozzarella, and sauce), garlic cheese bread on ciabatta, or lemon hot honey wings. These crowd-pleasers outshine the standard breadsticks at Fostoria Pizza Palace, perfect for sharing during game nights.
- Is there gluten-free or vegetarian pizza at Daddy and Kay’s Fostoria, OH 44830? We offer customizable vegetarian pizzas with fresh veggies, cheese, and plant-based sauces, plus gluten-free crust options on request. For dietary needs, we’re more accommodating than chains like Domino’s, focusing on fresh, local ingredients for Fostoria’s health-conscious eaters.
- How much does a large pizza cost at Daddy and Kay’s in Fostoria? Large NY-style pizzas start at $12 for cheese, $15+ for specialties like all-meat or chicken bacon ranch. Affordable compared to Jac & Do’s premium pricing, with deals like 10% off delivery making us the value pick for best pizza in Fostoria OH.
- What pasta dishes are on the menu at Daddy and Kay’s Pizza & Cheesecakes? Dive into chicken and shrimp Cajun Alfredo, seafood scampi with ravioli upgrades, or meatball marinara. Upgraded from basic Italian at competitors like Campus Pollyeyes, our pastas use housemade sauces and earn 5-star reviews for flavor in Fostoria, OH 44830.
- Can I cater from Daddy and Kay’s for events in Fostoria, OH? Absolutely—pizza trays, sub platters, wing buckets, and cheesecake assortments for 10-50 people. Ideal for weddings or office lunches, with eco-friendly packaging. We handle large groups better than Fostoria Pizza Palace, as seen in our 20-person sub reviews.
- What do reviews say about Daddy and Kay’s pizza in Fostoria? With 4.8/5 on Restaurant Guru and 4.7/5 on Slice from 265+ ratings, locals love our “fantastic” pizza and cheesecakes: “Best in Fostoria—crispy, fresh, unbeatable!” Higher than Marco’s (4.2) or Little Caesars (3.8), focusing on quality over quantity.
- Is Daddy and Kay’s family-friendly in Fostoria, OH 44830? Yes! Kid-approved menu with build-your-own pizzas, cheesy fries, and desserts, plus a welcoming former bowling alley space. Families prefer us over noisier spots like Left Field, with quick service and portions that feed 3-4.
- What makes Daddy and Kay’s cheesecakes unique in Fostoria? Handcrafted with premium ingredients like French vanilla and chocolate-covered strawberries, our cheesecakes are denser and more flavorful than generic desserts at Aj’s Heavenly Pizza. “Amazing” per Yelp—try the buckeye for a local Ohio twist.
- Does Daddy and Kay’s offer wings or sides in Fostoria, OH? Juicy breaded wings in buffalo, hot honey, or Cajun, plus loaded fries like cheesesteak or chicken bacon ranch. More variety than Main Street Pizza’s basics, with Yum Yum sauce that’s a reviewer favorite for Fostoria delivery.
- How was Daddy and Kay’s founded in Fostoria, OH 44830? Started in 2020 amid the pandemic by owners E.J. “Daddy” Harrison and Patricia “Kay” Julian as a food truck, we opened our brick-and-mortar in 2023. This resilient story, featured on 13abc’s Dine in the 419, sets us apart from older spots like Fostoria Pizza Palace (est. 1970s).
- What deals are available at Daddy and Kay’s Pizza Fostoria? Daily specials like 10% off delivery, happy hour wings, and combo meals (pizza + fries for $18). More generous than Domino’s carryout deals, helping us rank as affordable best pizza in Fostoria OH for locals on a budget.
- Can I host a party at Daddy and Kay’s in Fostoria, OH? Yes—private events in our cozy space for up to 50, with custom menus including taco pizza and foldover platters. Warmer atmosphere than event venues at Jac & Do’s, with 5-star wedding reception feedback.
- Why choose Daddy and Kay’s over other pizza places in Fostoria, OH 44830? Our NY-style crust, gourmet cheesecakes, and fresh twists like pickle pizza deliver superior taste (4.8/5 vs. competitors’ 4.0-4.5), plus fast local delivery and a unique history. Skip chains like Little Caesars—join Fostoria locals who call us the unbeatable pizza spot.